Is vinyl bad for the environment? As Billie Eilish slams musicians over ... trends now

Is vinyl bad for the environment? As Billie Eilish slams musicians over ... trends now

Billie Eilish hit the headlines this week after she critisized her music industry peers over their 'wasteful' practice of releasing numerous vinyl versions of albums to increase sales.

During an interview with Billboard, the 22-year-old Grammy winner said: 'I can't even express to you how wasteful it is.

'I find it really frustrating as somebody who really goes out of my way to be sustainable and do the best that I can and try to involve everybody in my team in being sustainable.'

But is Billie right? 

MailOnline spoke to experts to understand the true impact of your favourite vinyl records on the environment. 

Billie Eilish hit the headlines this week after she critisized her music industry peers over their 'wasteful' practice of releasing numerous vinyl versions of albums to increase sales

Billie Eilish hit the headlines this week after she critisized her music industry peers over their 'wasteful' practice of releasing numerous vinyl versions of albums to increase sales 

Are vinyl records bad for the environment? 

The creation of an average vinyl record produces around 1kg of CO2.

50 per cent of that comes from the PVC, so records made of recycled PVC are much better for the environment.

The average record has the same carbon footprint as streaming an album online for 17 hours.

However, albums are very rarely thrown out so are not 'wasted' in the sense of ending up in landfills.  

Advertisement

'We live in this day and age where, for some reason, it’s very important to some artists to make all sorts of different vinyl and packaging,' Billie said in the interview, adding that 'people' are 'just getting away with it.'

While the Oscar-winning musician later said she wasn't singling anyone out, many took this to be a dig at Taylor Swift.

Swift has established herself as the unrivalled queen of vinyl sales in recent years, selling 3.4 million records in the US in 2023, representing seven per cent of all sales.

For context, only 5.9 million records were sold in the whole of the UK that year, of which 85,000 were Swift's 1989 (Taylor's Version).

However, Swift also releases multiple variants of the same album, offering different colours or album art.

Although Eilish herself released eight versions of her album Happier Than Ever, she claims that such practices are 'really frustrating as somebody who really goes out of my way to be sustainable'.

Eilish is not alone in her concerns about the potential impact of vinyl records.

Records are made by pressing pellets of polyvinyl chloride (PVC) into grooved moulds under high heat pressure.  

Eilish criticised artists for releasing multiple versions of a single album. Taylor Swift recently released four different colour variations of 1999 (Taylor's Version) (pictured)

Eilish criticised artists for releasing multiple versions of a single album. Taylor Swift recently released four different colour variations of 1999 (Taylor's Version) (pictured) 

Billie Eilish herself released eight different colour variations of Happier Than Ever (pictured), although these were made with recycled vinyl

Billie Eilish herself released eight different colour variations of Happier Than Ever (pictured), although these were made with recycled vinyl

NEXT Move over, Gnasher! The Beano will feature a guide dog for first time to raise ... trends now