Minister insists people SHOULD wear masks in crowded places

Minister insists people SHOULD wear masks in crowded places
Minister insists people SHOULD wear masks in crowded places

A minister risked more mixed messaging on masks today insisting people should wear them in crowded spaces and they could be compulsory on trains - but they will not be legally required.

Health minister Edward Argar insisted people will not be 'confused' by the rules as they can exercise 'common sense judgment' in deciding whether to use face coverings.

The comments came after Health Secretary Sajid Javid suggested it would be 'irresponsible' not to wear masks in crowded places.

And 'Freedom Day' guidance being issued later is set to say they are 'expected' in some circumstances. 

However, Cabinet ministers Rishi Sunak and Robert Jenrick previously indicated they are keen to ditch masks as soon as they are no longer mandatory.  

Mr Argar raised fresh doubt about whether there will be a genuine removal of restrictions in a round of interviews this morning, saying train companies may well look at demanding them as a 'condition of carriage'.

'But at a governmental level, what we have set out, what we will be looking to do is see the legal requirements fall away but for guidance – strong guidance and cautious guidance – to be in place for people to exercise their common sense,' he added.

Asked about former Tory leader Iain Duncan Smith complaining that the stance risks creating confusion, Mr Argar replied: 'I don't think that the British people will struggle to look at the guidance and form their own common-sense judgment – I don't think it will introduce confusion.

'I think people will look at it, they will form a sensible judgment based on the guidance.'

Mr Argar said he personally would 'continue to carry my face mask in my jacket pocket'.

'The sort of circumstances where I would wear it, where I would encourage others to do so, are the sort of things that Chris Whitty, the chief medical officer set out a week or so again,' he told LBC.

'If, for example, you are in a crowded train, if you are in a setting like a hospital where the relevant authority requires you to wear it, or where, as common courtesy, if you are in an indoor environment with someone who clearly feels uncomfortable with you not wearing it, it would be common courtesy to put it on then – that's how I would behave.'   

Health minister Edward Argar pointed to the 'defensive wall' being provided by vaccines. 'If not now, when?' he said of lifting the legal restrictions

Health minister Edward Argar pointed to the 'defensive wall' being provided by vaccines. 'If not now, when?' he said of lifting the legal restrictions

Boris Johnson (pictured running this morning) will give the final go-ahead for 'Freedom Day' on July 19 later - but send a stark message that people need to keep being careful amid spiking cases

Boris Johnson (pictured running this morning) will give the final go-ahead for 'Freedom Day' on July 19 later - but send a stark message that people need to keep being careful amid spiking cases

Boris Johnson will today warn that people should 'expect' to keep wearing masks in enclosed spaces such as supermarkets and trains even after Covid restrictions are lifted on July 19

Boris Johnson will today warn that people should 'expect' to keep wearing masks in enclosed spaces such as supermarkets and trains even after Covid restrictions are lifted on July 19

Not the law, but 'expected': Boris's fudge on face masks 

The legal requirement to wear a face mask in England is expected to be scrapped from July 19.

Prime Minister Boris Johnson has said it will be a matter of 'personal responsibility', while transport operators and places such as shops are likely to decide their own policy on the issue.

How are the rules on face masks changing?

Almost all the remaining Covid restrictions in England will be removed on July 19 if the Prime Minister confirms the move on Monday afternoon.

The legal requirement to wear a face covering is due to end but official guidance will say they should still be worn in some settings as a voluntary measure.

Vaccines minister Nadhim Zahawi said on Sunday: 'The guidelines will be very clear on things like mask-wearing. There's an expectation of people to wear masks indoors, in crowded places, on public transport.'

What do scientists think?

The British Medical Association (BMA), which represents doctors, says there should be an 'ongoing requirement' to wear a mask in enclosed public spaces, such as public transport, shops and healthcare settings.

Dr Mike Tildesley, from the University of Warwick and a member of the Scientific Pandemic Influenza Group on Modelling (Spi-M) group, said on Monday there had been 'mixed messaging' over face masks from the Government, even in the last few days.

'I think it's quite confusing actually for people to know what the right thing to do is,' he said. 'I think all that we can do is take a sort of appropriate approach where we look at the situation and sort of weigh up the risk ourselves and I hope that enough people do that going forward that we don't see a big surge.'

Other experts appear divided on whether people in England should be asked to continue to wear face masks after July 19.

Paul Hunter, professor in medicine at the University of East Anglia, said he thought lifting face mask restrictions was OK, though people who are vulnerable may wish to take extra care.

Meanwhile, Robert Dingwall, professor of sociology at Nottingham Trent University, said it makes sense to make them voluntary, adding: 'The benefits of masks have always been uncertain because the quality of the evidence in both directions is so weak.'

But Dr Laurence Aitchison, from the department of computer science at the University of Bristol, said: 'Our research has shown mask-wearing reduces the spread of Covid-19 by around 25% if everyone wears them.'

Is there more evidence on the benefit of face masks?

Yes. Research suggests that face coverings worn over the nose and mouth reduce the spread of coronavirus droplets from coughs, sneezes and speaking.

The main purpose is to protect others from Covid, but there is some evidence they also protect the wearer.

One Royal Society report last summer found that the use of cotton masks was associated with 54% lower odds of infection in comparison with the no-mask groups, when tested in a healthcare setting.

In another study, published in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, scientists calculated that wearing face coverings prevented more than 78,000 infections in Italy between April 6 and May 9 2020, and more than 66,000 infections in New York City over just a few weeks.

A report recently published by the Royal Society suggests that even basic homemade face coverings can reduce transmission if enough people wear them when in public.

The study, based on mathematical modelling, showed that if an entire population wore face coverings that were only 75% effective, it would bring the reproduction number (the R) from 4.0 to under 1.0, without the need for lockdowns.

What do people need to know about wearing masks?

Ideally, face coverings should be made of multi-layers of high quality cotton.

People are advised to sanitise their hands before putting one on and removing it, and to wash masks daily.

When wearing a face covering, it should cover the mouth and nose, with no gaps.

Many experts believe face masks are better seen as part of a package of measures, which includes things such as social distancing.

Advertisement

The latest Covid wrangling came as:  

No 10 issued figures showing Covid vaccines have saved 30,000 lives and prevented 8.5million infections in England alone. Dr Susan Hopkins of PHE warned that hospitalisations could soar to 4,000 a day by the end of the summer, the same level as at the peak in January.  Another 31,772 new Covid cases were recorded but there were signs the rate of growth is slowing and the 26 deaths recorded in the past 24 hours are a fraction of the toll seen at the peak of the pandemic. 

Boris Johnson will give the final go-ahead for 'Freedom Day' on July 19 today - but send a stark message that people need to keep being careful amid spiking cases.

The Prime Minister will use a Downing Street press conference to confirm the unlocking next Monday, with almost all legal restrictions to be axed in England.

But he will caution that the dramatic easing 'comes with a warning', and people must 'expect' to keep wearing masks in enclosed spaces such as supermarkets and trains. 

Government experts have suggested working from home and social distancing should remain the norm after the shift to trusting the public's 'common sense'. There are fears that hospitalisations could hit 3,000 a day soon as the Delta variant continues to run riot.

Manchester Mayor Andy Burnham today renewed his assault over dropping the legal requirement to wear face coverings on public transport.   

But health minister Edward Argar pointed to the 'defensive wall' being provided by vaccines. 'If not now, when?' he said of lifting the legal restrictions. 

In a statement ahead of a Covid O meeting this morning to sign off the plans, and his press briefing at 5pm, the PM said that cases will inevitably continue to rise as restrictions are eased.

'Caution is absolutely vital, and we must all take responsibility so we don't undo our progress, ensuring we continue to protect our NHS,' he said.  

The 'Freedom Day' was meant to herald a return to normality but the PM will also publish new 'guidance' setting out precautions people should continue to take.

Mr Johnson will say England is 'tantalisingly close to the final milestone in our road map out of lockdown, but the plan to restore our freedoms must come with a warning.' 

He will insist

read more from dailymail.....

NEXT Doctors first 'dismissed' this young girl's cancer symptom before her parents ... trends now