Defiant headteacher Katharine Birbalsingh tells parents 'if you don't like it, ... trends now

Defiant headteacher Katharine Birbalsingh tells parents 'if you don't like it, ... trends now
Defiant headteacher Katharine Birbalsingh tells parents 'if you don't like it, ... trends now

Defiant headteacher Katharine Birbalsingh tells parents 'if you don't like it, ... trends now

A defiant headteacher of a school which has won the right to ban Muslim prayer rituals has told parents 'if you don't like it, don't come to us' amid the threat of further legal action.  

Katharine Birbalsingh, who has been called Britain's strictest head, said the landmark ruling was a 'victory for all schools' as she hit out at 'bullying identity politics'.

The Government's former social mobility tsar also declared we need the 'honesty' to call out 'deep-seated progressivist racism' in society. 

A pupil at her Michaela Community School in Wembley, north-west London, had claimed a ban on prayer rituals was a breach of her human rights and violated the Equality Act.

But the High Court yesterday ruled the ban was both proportionate and justified and that Miss Birbalsingh should be allowed to enforce the school's secular ethos.

After claiming victory, Miss Birbalsingh said: 'If parents do not like what Michaela is, they do not need to send their children to us.'

In a lengthy statement, she also questioned why the Muslim pupil received '£150,000 in legal aid' to fight her case - and fears the family may launch further action.

Katharine Birbalsingh, who has been called Britain's strictest head, said the landmark ruling was a 'victory for all schools' as she hit out at 'bullying identity politics'

Katharine Birbalsingh, who has been called Britain's strictest head, said the landmark ruling was a 'victory for all schools' as she hit out at 'bullying identity politics'

Michaela Community School was targeted with death threats and abuse, the court was told

Michaela Community School was targeted with death threats and abuse, the court was told

Equalities minister Kemi Badenoch (pictured) said it was 'a victory against activists trying to subvert our public institutions'

Equalities minister Kemi Badenoch (pictured) said it was 'a victory against activists trying to subvert our public institutions'

How a school's prayer rituals ban led to a High Court challenge 

A Muslim student at a London school has lost a High Court challenge against its ban on prayer rituals.

But how did events unfold?

- Autumn term 2022 and start of term 2023

Pupils began talking about the possibility of praying at the school, the student said.

- March 17 2023

One of the teachers saw a Year 9 pupil praying in the yard during the lunch break, using their blazer as a prayer mat.

Headteacher Katharine Birbalsingh was informed but she did not intervene because this was within the school rules at the time.

- March 22 2023

Around 20 Year 9 children prayed in the yard using prayer mats.

Ms Birbalsingh said there was a 'high degree of concern and unease' among teachers and pupils as prayer rituals had not been conducted at the school before.

A large number of Year 9 girls had co-ordinated with each other to bring in prayer mats without permission, despite this being against the rules.

- March 23 2023

A senior teacher told children to put the prayer mats away as they were against school policy, but two students answered back to her.

- March 24 2023

There were around 30 pupils praying in the yard, including from years 7 and 11.

On the same day, an online petition started, accusing the senior teacher of 'disgusting, Islamophobic behaviour' the previous day, and was signed by at least 4,000 people.

Ms Birbalsingh and the teacher were targeted with death threats, abuse and allegations of Islamophobia.

- March 25 and 26 2023

An email was sent to the school saying several bombs had been planted in the building.

Ms Birbalsingh spoke with the school's senior leadership team, and they agreed to ban prayer rituals.

- March 27 2023

Police searched the school for explosives, nothing was found.

The ban on prayer rituals was enforced by teachers and two security guards were hired amid threats.

- May 23 2023

The school's governing body voted to introduce the ritual prayer policy.

- January 16 2024

The student brought a High Court challenge against the school, alleging that the policy was discriminatory and had 'fundamentally changed' how she felt 'about being a Muslim in this country'.

- April 16 2024

Mr Justice Linden dismissed the pupil's arguments, saying there was 'a rational connection between the aim of promoting the team ethos of the school, inclusivity, social cohesion etc and the prayer ritual policy'.

He said: 'The disadvantage to Muslim pupils at the school caused by the prayer ritual policy is in my view outweighed by the aims which it seeks to promote in the interests of the school community as a whole, including Muslim pupils.'

Source: PA 

Advertisement

She asked: 'Can it be right for a family to receive £150,000 of taxpayer-funded legal aid to bring a case like this?  

She claimed the pupil's mother, who helped her daughter bring the case, intended to send another child to the school. 

Ms Birbalsingh alleged: 'At the same time, this mum has sent a letter to our lawyers suggesting that she may take us to court yet again over another issue at the school she doesn't like, presumably once again at the taxpayer's expense.'

A representative for the family said the figure included in Ms Birbalsingh's statement was incorrect, with the pupil's capped legal aid costs being lower than that sum. The representative did not comment on the suggestion of further legal action.

Elsewhere in her statement, Ms Birbalsingh said: 'If our families did not like the school, they would not repeatedly choose to send their children to Michaela.

'At the two welcome events that all parents must attend before sending their child to Michaela, I run through everything that makes Michaela different to other schools: constant supervision, family lunch, silent corridors, no prayer room, easy ways to get detention, strict uniform etc.'

She then said if parent's don't like what the school is, they should not send their children there. 

Equalities minister Kemi Badenoch said it was 'a victory against activists trying to subvert our public institutions'. She added: 'The Equality Act is a shield, not a sword, and teachers must not be threatened.'

The case, which was brought with taxpayer-funded legal aid, will have wide implications for state schools under pressure from hardline religious groups. 

The decision was welcomed by Downing Street, which said 'heads are best placed to take decisions on what takes place in their school including how to accommodate prayer'.

And Education Secretary Gillian Keegan said it would give all heads the confidence to 'make the right decision for their school'.

Miss Birbalsingh became known as the country's strictest head for her uncompromising rules.

She enforces a secular ethos at Michaela, despite 50 per cent of pupils being Muslim, to ensure children can make friends 'across religious divides'. But according to her evidence to the court, a group of pupils started coordinated prayer rituals in the playground in March last year.

Some also 'intimidated' other pupils for refusing to fast during Ramadan, by 'staring' and 'declining to talk to them'. 

One girl had been 'intimidated' into wearing a headscarf, and another had dropped out of the school choir after being told it was 'forbidden during Ramadan'. 

The pupil bringing the case, who cannot be identified for legal reasons, was given a fixed-term exclusion for being 'rude and aggressive' when a teacher told her to put away her prayer mat.

After that incident, a campaign of harassment started from the wider community, according to Miss Birbalsingh. 

An online petition accusing the school of Islamophobia garnered 4,000 signatures, and the court heard accompanying comments directed racist abuse at the teacher involved.

A brick was thrown through the window of another teacher's home, and the school had a bomb threat which later turned out to be a hoax.

Determined not to give in to threats, Miss Birbalsingh and the governors then officially prohibited pupils from performing prayer rituals.

The girl, supported by her mother, launched action via law firm Simpson Millar, which argued she should be allowed to pray for around five minutes at lunch, on dates when faith rules required it. 

But yesterday, Mr Justice Linden concluded the ban did not interfere with her religious freedom and helped to achieve the 'legitimate' aim of promoting an ethos of inclusivity and social cohesion.

Miss Birbalsingh said in a statement afterwards: 'There is a false narrative that some try to paint about Muslims being an oppressed minority at our school. 

'They are, in fact, the largest group. Those who are most at risk are other minorities and Muslim children who are less observant.'

She claimed the girl's mother still intends to send her younger sibling to the school.

The school's headteacher Katharine Birbalsingh has questioned why the Muslim pupil was given '£150,000 in legal aid'

The school's headteacher Katharine Birbalsingh has questioned why the Muslim pupil was given '£150,000 in legal aid'

Following the decision, Education Secretary Gillian Keegan (pictured) said the ruling 'should give all school leaders confidence in making the right decision for their school while prioritising tolerance and respect between those of different faiths and none'

Following the decision, Education Secretary Gillian Keegan (pictured) said the ruling 'should give all school leaders confidence in making the right decision for their school while prioritising tolerance and respect between those of different faiths and none'

Despite catering to a deprived area, Michaela is one of the best performing state secondary schools in the country and rated outstanding by Ofsted.

The pupil who lost the case said: 'Even though I lost, I still feel that I did the right thing in seeking to challenge the ban. I tried my best and was true to myself and my religion.'

Her mother said: 'Her courage in pursuing this matter fills me with pride and I'm confident she's gained invaluable lessons.'

Secular campaigners said the ruling serves as a reminder that claims of religious freedom 'do not trump all other

read more from dailymail.....

PREV UCLA medical residents tell lecture it is wrong to 'stigmatize' people who burn ... trends now
NEXT Doctors first 'dismissed' this young girl's cancer symptom before her parents ... trends now