At last, we might finally get the banking hubs we need, says JEFF PRESTRIDGE

At last, we might finally get the banking hubs we need, says JEFF PRESTRIDGE
By: dailymail Posted On: August 26, 2024 View: 167

It seems that the rules governing the opening (and running) of one-stop banking hubs could soon be relaxed. 

If so, it will be great news for many communities which to date have not met the strict eligibility criteria laid down by the banks for a hub to be established.

It could also result in existing hubs providing a wider range of banking services than currently, increasing their relevance to consumers and small businesses. 

Hope on the horizon? It seems that the rules governing the opening (and running) of one-stop banking hubs could soon be relaxed

For those of you who are unfamiliar with hubs, they are community banks that, under one roof, offer basic services for personal and small business customers of all the mainstream banks.

Their set-up costs are funded by the big banks via an organisation called Cash Access UK and are run by the Post Office. 

Staff from the big banks are on hand once a week to offer face-to-face advice. So far, 147 have been given the go ahead although only 71 are open for business (finding suitable premises is often a nightmare).

Currently, hubs are only permitted in towns that have lost their last bank branch. But a town without a bank does not automatically guarantee a hub. Far from it.

Labour¿s Tulip Siddiq is Economic Secretary to the Treasury

Parsimonious with their own money, the banks have so far laid down strict conditions governing their opening.

First, the town must be deemed ‘big’ enough to support one (rather subjective). It then can’t have a branch of Nationwide on its high street because the banks believe the building society’s presence makes the requirement for a hub redundant.

As banking expert and community bank champion Derek French has long argued, this is patently not true (no surprises there) because Nationwide does not offer banking services to small businesses. 

So if a town is left with a Nationwide and no banks, local small businesses are left with minimal access to high street banking. 

An unsatisfactory state of affairs – French’s home town of Harpenden is caught in just such a position.

Yet it seems the banks are now being forced to have a hub rethink. Not because they have suddenly come over all gooey-eyed, but as a result of pressure from the new Government which wants 350 hubs up and running by 2029 as part of its ambitious plan for revitalising the country’s struggling high streets. 

One of Labour’s few good ideas so far, which probably means it will soon die a death. Sources within the banking industry tell me that a vote among the banks on relaxing their criteria for hub openings is currently taking place.

If ‘relaxation’ gets the go ahead – we should know early next month – it could mean up to 20 towns previously denied a hub because of having a Nationwide branch being granted one. Hurrah, I say.

Towns where the Nationwide branches have restricted opening hours – for example Kenilworth in Warwickshire and Rugeley in Staffordshire – will be prioritised. Harpenden should also get a hub.

Going forward, towns left bankless when the last branch shuts will then not be automatically denied a hub because a Nationwide branch sits on its high street. 

This should increase the rate of new hub openings and the chances of Labour’s promise of 350 hubs being met.

Alongside this push for more hubs, the banks are also likely to come under extreme pressure to improve the services they offer through them. Labour’s Tulip Siddiq, Economic Secretary to the Treasury, is keen to make headway on this issue – and she is absolutely right in her line of thinking.

Earlier this year I went up to Cambuslang on the outskirts of Glasgow to visit its successful hub. 

Community representatives that I met there said the hub could have a far wider rejuvenating impact on the local area if only its services were broadened and opening hours extended.

I do like to be beside the sea... if cash comes free

Outrageous: It is scandalous that Brighton railway station does not have a free-to-use cash machine on its premises

It's good to be back at work after a revitalising week away scouting out potential places to live in Brighton, East Sussex – as well as swim in the sea (no jelly fish encountered), walk on the South Downs, take in the beauty of Devil’s Dyke and marvel at restaurateur Jane Bom-Bane entertaining her customers by singing while wearing a model house on her head.

Yes, utterly bizarre, but this troubled world needs eccentric characters like Jane to keep us all sane.

Work, of course, was never far away. I will make two banking observations from my time in glorious Sussex.

First, it is scandalous that Brighton railway station – a seething mass of humanity at all hours of the day and most of the night – does not have a free-to-use cash machine on its premises.

Instead, those scrambling for cash are faced with a bank of ATMs that demand a withdrawal fee of £1.99. ‘There where you need us,’ the screens bark.

No, what Brighton station needs are free-to-use ATMs. Cash machine network Link, a champion of free access to cash, should come to the rescue.

Secondly, it was a pleasure to visit the seaside town of Eastbourne – and not just to see a majestic Lancaster Bomber rule the cloudless blue skies for ten minutes as part of the town’s annual air show.

What struck me as I walked through the town to the seafront was the plethora of bank branches open for business (all the big brands were on show). It was a joy to behold.

Maybe Eastbourne’s thriving banks are a reflection of its predominantly elderly population who prefer personal service to dealing with soulless machines. And maybe, despite that, some will still close in the near future.

But I am convinced that they play a key part in giving Eastbourne’s high street a vibrancy other bankless towns lost long ago. 

Labour’s Tulip Siddiq, a champion of thriving high streets with accessible banking services, should visit. While doing so, she could also listen to the many residents who have been stripped of their winter fuel payment by her boss Rachel Reeves.

They also liked the idea of the community bank becoming more of a community hub – incorporating other key services such as advice on eligibility for benefits (pension credit, for example) and maybe a mini-library.

These are great ideas that should be championed by Siddiq.

The gaps in banking services at hubs are currently horrible – and frankly unacceptable. 

For example, new bank accounts cannot be opened. This is madness given staff from the main banks are on site at all hubs on specific days.

Surely, these bank employees should be empowered to help people open new accounts – and thereby generate new business (and revenues) for their employer. Everyone wins: the bank, the hub and local people.

Even really basic tasks such as printing out a customer’s bank statement cannot be done at a hub. Talk about minimalist banking. It’s unacceptable and Siddiq is right to want the banks to raise their game.

So far, the banks have been reluctant backers of hubs – investing the minimum in a concept which they believe (and hope) will only be temporary as banking becomes mobile dominated and the need for cash withers on the vine.

Yet, it seems a bit of political muscle will now force them to accept that hubs – and smarter ones at that – are actually here to stay. They are the small price they must pay for taking an axe to their individual branch networks.

Let’s hope the banks do the sensible thing and vote for a future that permits hubs to flourish where once their own branches stood proud. We deserve no less.

SAVE MONEY, MAKE MONEY

Affiliate links: If you take out a product This is Money may earn a commission. These deals are chosen by our editorial team, as we think they are worth highlighting. This does not affect our editorial independence.

Read this on dailymail
  Contact Us
  Follow Us
  About

Read the latest local and international news from trusted sources in one place.